One Day in December by Josie Silver
Genre: Romance, Seasonal
Two people. Ten chances. One unforgettable love story.
Two people. Ten chances. One unforgettable love story.
Laurie is pretty sure love at first sight doesn’t exist anywhere but the movies. But then, through a misted-up bus window one snowy December day, she sees a man who she knows instantly is the one. Their eyes meet, there’s a moment of pure magic…and then her bus drives away.
Certain they’re fated to find each other again, Laurie spends a year scanning every bus stop and cafe in London for him. But she doesn’t find him, not when it matters anyway. Instead they “reunite” at a Christmas party, when her best friend Sarah giddily introduces her new boyfriend to Laurie. It’s Jack, the man from the bus. It would be.
What follows for Laurie, Sarah and Jack is ten years of riendship, heartbreak, missed opportunities, roads not taken, and destinies reconsidered. One Day in December is a joyous, heartwarming and immensely moving love story to escape into and a reminder that fate takes inexplicable turns along the route to happiness.From JosieSilver.com
A few weeks before Christmas, this book kept showing up alllll over my Instagram feed. Everyone seemed to be currently reading it, or had already read and loved it. In fact, I saw one woman I follow mention that this book played a part in her now-fiancé’s proposal? When I saw that, I decided I had to know what the fuss was all about, and bought it.
Maybe it’s because I’m just super basic, but anything that takes place in London in the 2000s immediately reminds me of Love Actually. Not that that’s a bad thing. Or a good thing. Okay, I am a little embarrassed by it, it’s fine.
The beginning scene is fantastical enough to make you kind of scoff… but also immediately turn the page and continue reading. We’re introduced to our heroine, Laurie, as she sits on a bus in London, and makes eye contact with her soulmate: a man who sits at the bus stop outside. She immediately knows he’s her soulmate, and the reader watches as he seemingly realizes it too, and tries to make his way onto the bus, but to no avail. The bus and Laurie drive off, leaving her dream man alone in the snow.
When Laurie returns home, she immediately does the logical thing that almost every woman would do: she tells her best friend. Sarah and Laurie have been roommates for years, and now are as close as sisters. Laurie tells Sarah about the man, and Sarah, in true best friend fashion, laments with her, and the two spend the next year looking for Laurie’s soulmate.
And they find him! But… not in the way Laurie would hope for at all. The following year, Sarah introduces Laurie to her new boyfriend, Jack, who is (unbeknownst to Sarah) the man Laurie saw on the bus. Thus begins a decade of love, loss, and friendship for Laurie, Jack, and Sarah. I pretty much knew how the book would end the moment I began reading it, but what was in the middle of the story was a complete surprise to me.
I usually find stories like this to be a little tricky. I don’t like stories that pit friendship against “true love”. But, I was pleasantly surprised with how One Day in December went about telling Jack and Laurie’s story.
I never disliked Sarah, who Jack initially dated, and neither did Laurie. Laurie put her friendship with Sarah before any perusal of a relationship with Jack. For the most part. Except for the scene (and this is a minor spoiler!) where Jack kisses her because she’s upset and then they decide not to tell Sarah. That part pissed me off.
While Laurie always does love Jack, I appreciated how her life didn’t always revolve around him. There were times when she loved him as a friend, or as a brother, and she was seeing other people. Of course those were the times when Jack was head over heels in love, which further proves my point that men are stupid.
Another part that kind of made me mad was the fact that (another spoiler!) Sarah didn’t go to Laurie’s wedding because she had just found out that she and Jack kissed? I didn’t find that to be very believable. The Sarah I had gotten to know would have done, and did do anything for Laurie. And I understand that Sarah was upset, and really, who wouldn’t be in that situation? But she was dating and in love with someone else, and it was literally right before Laurie’s wedding. Obviously Laurie had moved on, and regretted not coming clean sooner. I didn’t buy it that Sarah would abandon Laurie on her wedding day. Nope. Not even a little bit.
I also wasn’t the biggest fan of how the book handled Oscar, Laurie’s partner in the book. It felt like his purpose was just to be an obstacle to Laurie and Jack being together. I also think that Laurie was able to get to know herself and what she wanted from life after being with him. But the whole relationship felt bizarre to me. Oscar and Laurie met on vacation and pretty much had a whirl-wind, fantastical romance. It didn’t feel real when I was reading about it. I liked Oscar, and his final scenes seemed to be out of character. He demanded that Laurie make these huge life changes for him, when he had never been like that before? It just felt strange to me.
Which leads me to Jack. Honestly, I think that Jack is probably the most realistic portrayal of a man in a romance book that I’ve ever read. Maybe to its detriment. When I’m reading a romance book, I don’t really want to be reminded that men ain’t shit. There were times when, honestly, Jack was a dick. When Laurie asked if he remembered seeing her on the bus, he lied. He was in a relationship with Sarah when Laurie asked him, and he pretty much gaslit her and was like “nah girl, you crazy.” Part of me gets it, like he was in a relationship with Sarah, so it would have been kind of weird to admit, but also… what’s stopping them from having an honest, adult conversation about it? This scene also hurts my heart a bit, because it shows that he was still hung up on the fantasy of Laurie, and that Sarah would always come second to her. Sarah didn’t deserve that.
But then everything is forgiven in the last… fifty or so pages of the book. I swear, the ending is absolutely magical, and made me believe in the power of love again. Most of the problems I had with the book were wiped away because of this ending. It was big and extravagant and satisfying, and honestly, I will recommend this book to the entire world, just so everyone gets to experience it.
If you’d like to purchase this book for yourself, please consider purchasing from an independent bookstore, or if that isn’t possible for you, please consider using my Amazon Affiliate Link below!